(Long and SPOILER filled, for both the 6th movie and the 7th book so watch the heck out)
It's a tricky thing, adapting a book into a movie. Particularly one that's been read, analyzed, dissected, fought over, and devoured millions of times over. You keep it too tightly to the book and it would no doubt be long and dry. Go too far off base and you hear the unending outcry of an angry horde of rabid fans from across the globe. It's basically a no-win situation, if you discount the huge piles of money that you're being paid.
I think that overall, though, I'm in the camp that likes it when things are switched up. My favorite of the Harry Potter movies is Alfonso CuarĂ³n's take on Prisoner of Azkaban, and I think it's mostly because the movie doesn't try to copy over the book word for word (like it seemed the first two tried to) and it didn't just try to get all the set pieces of the story in (like the 4th seemed to). There was a story that was told, and even though the denouement exposition scene was probably too much, it felt like a standalone decent film.
David Yates is obviously taking a long-term approach with parts 5 through 7A & 7B that doesn't really fit any classification. He's taking a sort of half-and-half approach to adaptation that you can only try when you know you're going to have the continuity of the films in place. Because just like 5, 6 really doesn't stand on it's own as a great film. Don't get me wrong, it's almost endlessly entertaining. For a movie that runs over two and half hours, keeping my attention that high and engrossed throughout is a great triumph. But he's obviously taking the long view on the series as a whole, and is okay with making the 6th installment fun, but ultimately incomplete. And if the currently leaked plans for the first movie of the seventh book are accurate, this will continue to the end.
This isn't necessarily a bad thing (cohesion rarely is), but it's not what I would have done. We'll get into that later, but let's for now have a small discussion on how much I enjoyed this one.
My primary joy in this movie was the strength of acting, which is the highest it's been in an HP movie thus far. Particularly Emma Watson and Tom Felton, who brought up the level of their games significantly from Part 5. I could spend a few hours gushing over Watson, but mostly because I was terrified that after that Order of the Phoenix disaster, that she would drag this movie straight down, as Hermione has such an arc to get through in Half Blood Prince. But she pulls it off with room to spare. Felton adds some umph to Draco's story, and the decision to reveal a lot more about the vanishing cabinet directly was a very smart decision.
Plus, Michael Gambon as Dumbledore finally puts it all together for this movie, and just in time as he could have easily been the make or break piece of the puzzle. (This was sidestepped by the directing decisions, but we'll get to that). I wasn't on board with his acting style for part 4 at all, but by 5 I could come around to it, and in 6 he has real pathos - he obviously cares for Harry, and is doing a delicate balancing act that is nicely highlighted in some of the more subtle bits of his acting.
I also greatly enjoyed the little liberties that were taken with the book - I loved getting rid of the tedium of the Dursleys and instead getting the off-beat diner scene instead. That's the exact kind of thing I'm looking for in a movie adaptation - reverence to the spirit of the book, but not slavish devotion to the recreation of the text. I was less pleased with the added attack on the Weasleys' house, but that's more the plot nerd coming out in me than an actual complaint. The scene itself is incredibly well-done, it just raises so many canon questions that my brain starts flailing internally.
And just like for the last movie, lets stop and take a paragraph to revel in the glory that is Luna Lovegood. It's such a perfect bit of casting, and she's played so delightfully, I want an entire movie just about her and Harry having little adventures together. I loved the way she was integrated into the movie even better than in the book - her finding Harry on the train was economical and well thought-out, and she gets some great lines floating in and out of her various scenes. I can't say enough good things.
My last bit of gushing comes for the Horcrux reveal scene - which seems crazy, as it's something that I kind of hated in the book. Textually, when Harry gets the Slughorn memory, all it does is confirm Dumbledore's expectation of what is going on (basically the sum reveal is that he's expecting 7 horcruxes). This is similar to the movie, but Gambon is able to ham it up a little, and give it some gravitas. And then the bit that I didn't expect - the really nice foreshadowing for Book 7 - Dumbledore's explanation of how the dark magic leaves its traces, only to have Harry himself get hit with a bolt Voldemort when he touches the ring. Because he's got the dark traces inside himself, right? Since he's a horcrux too. And while they're a little overdone, I love the ambiguity of Dumbledore's lines that follow, about how he can't destroy the horcrux himself, and again he's going to have to ask too much of Harry. Because he doesn't really say which horcrux he's talking about, does he? Whatever, maybe I'm reading too much into it, but let me have my delusions, I think it's amazingly well done.
-------------------------
But back to the idea of adaptation. I understand what the director is doing here - he's going for the larger picture. The fifth movie sets the adult portion of the Harry Potter arc in motion - introduces the main characters and themes, but doesn't resolve much of anything. The sixth movie carries that through, raising the stakes by staying so close to the character-study side of things, rather than getting bogged into the deepening past plot. The opposite sides weighing in - the normal teenage life beset on all sides by the darkness - it makes sense when you're building to the overall conflict that will be Harry, Ron, and Hermione cutting ties to complete their mission in the next movie, and then the eventual grand conclusion where everything comes back together in the final one.
So taking this into account, I can see why the cuts were made where they were, and why the additions were necessary. It's a four movie payoff, nothing too immediate. See: Mrs. Weasley's long tear-stained reaction shot to Bellatrix burning down The Burrow. Can't even imagine what that might be leading up to a few movies down the road, no?
Or the cutting of all the other Voldemort memories: While it's all great backstory, it ultimately has little to do with the matters at hand in the story they're telling. How they'll nail down the horcruxes in the next parts is irrelevant to the set up the Half-Blood Prince is setting up. And for that matter, keeping the fight for Hogwarts at the end of HBP would introduce and remove the threat too quickly and too hollowly for the theme to continue (unless they re-added Bill and Fleur, which would be just too much.)
The only part I don't necessarily understand is the removal of the funeral, and the astronomy tower discussion put in its place. The new scene fits the theme well, but then so would the funeral. And had they carried the funeral to the expected conclusion, having Harry do his little homage to Spider-Man and dumping Ginny at the end would complete the natural arc of story nicely, and provides the ramp into the next movie. Instead we get a sort of soft fade out on the reflections of how the kids have grown up.
These are all things I can rail against, but don't see the need. It's a great entry into the series, and as a whole I think they'll acquit themselves nicely, particularly when viewed in the series as a whole.
Showing posts with label crazy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crazy. Show all posts
Monday, July 20, 2009
Thursday, October 09, 2008
Pathological Fears, a Revisitation
I've pretty extensively covered my list of irrational fears over the years, as it's something that I think about a lot. But after an experience a few weeks back, and my re-watching the movie Signs over the weekend, I've been once again put on notice by my brain that I even though I'm scared of a ton of things, those things continue to evolve constantly.
Most noticeably on the list of things that don't scare me anymore: I no longer have to keep my bed up against the corner of a room while I sleep (so as to have no way for anything to sneak up on me in the middle of the night). This one has been a gradual thing and is due to the layout of my bedroom requiring my bed to be offset from walls on all sides. In conjunction with this, I no longer get paranoid jags in which I think something/someone might be hiding under my bed. Which means that now I can get up to get a glass of water in the middle of the night without the fear that I'm about to get dragged down below. I like to think of these two abated fears as signs that I'm growing up.
Also, you can throw in the fact that I've gotten past the problem of not sleeping with my bedroom door open. Apparently the fear was that if someone broke into the house, they would have unfettered access to me (whereas a closed door is apparently akin to a brick wall. I don't know, don't blame me, these are irrational fears.) So, yeah, definitely growing up.
But not completely, as some things have remained constant on the irrational fears list:
Still can't sleep with the closet door open. This one is especially difficult because the shifting foundation of my building has caused the frame around my closet to cant by about 5 degrees, making closing the door physically impossible. So now I have to settle for wedging the door as close to closed as possible. Those last two inches of openness still make me nervous.
Also, I'm still afraid of clowns, but I continue to assert that this one doesn't belong on the irrational fears list. It's totally rational. Goddamn clowns.
-------------
Anyways, the whole point of this diatribe is that I've got two brand new fears that are way more prominent nowadays. See, I bought a new shower curtain a couple of weeks back. One of those fancy cloth numbers that goes on the outside of the plastic one, to give the illusion that you're a classy person. It's white and has stitched palm trees all over it, and it's pretty swank. It's also terribly heavy, which means that I have to keep it closed pretty much at all times, since my shower rod is notoriously wobbly and uneven weights on it cause it to come crashing down really unexpectedly.
As I learned at 3 AM on Tuesday last week, when I was startled awake by a crash so loud that I immediately assumed that the condo had finally been pushed to its limit and was collapsing all around me, House of Usher style. It was also in that brain-fogged moment that I realized I have no training in how to respond in cases of earthquake/house collapses. Mostly I just screamed like a girl and rolled off the bed like a ninja, only to get my legged wrapped up in the duvet and flopped to the ground face first.
So anyways, heavy shower curtain means I keep it closed at all times now. And now I am constantly -- constantly -- convinced that someone is hiding behind the curtain. Too many horror movies combined with New Fear #2 (below) and the time that I was 11 and my cousin hid in the shower to scare me while I was brushing my teeth have trained me to be so paranoid that I can barely function in my bathroom until I have spent a couple of hair-raising moments darting over to the shower and peeking around it to verify that I am indeed alone so I can wash my hands free of fear.
New Fear #2 is way more insidious and way more crazy too: I constantly imagine that I'm being stalked. This one has been hanging around a lot, but is more prominent after the Signs watching. See, a few weeks back, I was cleaning up the kitchen super late (like around 11:00pm) and needed to take out the trash, for fear that the Black Plague that I just scrubbed away would take on sentience in the trash bag and kill me in my sleep. So I wandered down to the dumpster on the far side of the complex.
(To understand the next part, you have to have some idea of the layout of the complex. This particular side doesn't border on the street, instead we're up against a mini-forest; it's the treeline to the little creek that runs out from the park to the north. So the layout goes Street-> Buildings -> Dumpster -> Lawn -> Trees.)
I toss the trash into the dumpster and turn to head back to my building. Midway through the turn, I swear I see someone across the lawn standing along the treeline, staring at me. More precisely, it's a white guy in a really dark suit. He's standing in the shadows of the trees, and it's just for a second as I'm turning, but I can still make out enough to tell he looks bald and is most definitely looking in my direction. I freak the hell out (as one does) and start heading back to my apartment double-time. Only when I turn back after a couple of seconds, there's no one standing there. More importantly, the lightpost on the lawn is brightly illuminating the place where I supposedly saw this person - there's no way that it would have been dark enough to hide someone in the shadows.
I chalk it up to a completely overactive imagination (which I've got in spades - ask me about my law library sub-basement stories sometime), and head home, only mildly still freaking out.
Now, ever since then, I'm constantly expecting this guy to pop up somewhere. Whenever I go outside at night, I'm looking everywhere, all the time, alert like a cougar. I've seen nothing since then, but it doesn't mean I'm not going crazy.
-------------
So yeah, I'm crazy like whoa. It's not unexpected, but still, it's a little sad.
Most noticeably on the list of things that don't scare me anymore: I no longer have to keep my bed up against the corner of a room while I sleep (so as to have no way for anything to sneak up on me in the middle of the night). This one has been a gradual thing and is due to the layout of my bedroom requiring my bed to be offset from walls on all sides. In conjunction with this, I no longer get paranoid jags in which I think something/someone might be hiding under my bed. Which means that now I can get up to get a glass of water in the middle of the night without the fear that I'm about to get dragged down below. I like to think of these two abated fears as signs that I'm growing up.
Also, you can throw in the fact that I've gotten past the problem of not sleeping with my bedroom door open. Apparently the fear was that if someone broke into the house, they would have unfettered access to me (whereas a closed door is apparently akin to a brick wall. I don't know, don't blame me, these are irrational fears.) So, yeah, definitely growing up.
But not completely, as some things have remained constant on the irrational fears list:
Still can't sleep with the closet door open. This one is especially difficult because the shifting foundation of my building has caused the frame around my closet to cant by about 5 degrees, making closing the door physically impossible. So now I have to settle for wedging the door as close to closed as possible. Those last two inches of openness still make me nervous.
Also, I'm still afraid of clowns, but I continue to assert that this one doesn't belong on the irrational fears list. It's totally rational. Goddamn clowns.
-------------
Anyways, the whole point of this diatribe is that I've got two brand new fears that are way more prominent nowadays. See, I bought a new shower curtain a couple of weeks back. One of those fancy cloth numbers that goes on the outside of the plastic one, to give the illusion that you're a classy person. It's white and has stitched palm trees all over it, and it's pretty swank. It's also terribly heavy, which means that I have to keep it closed pretty much at all times, since my shower rod is notoriously wobbly and uneven weights on it cause it to come crashing down really unexpectedly.
As I learned at 3 AM on Tuesday last week, when I was startled awake by a crash so loud that I immediately assumed that the condo had finally been pushed to its limit and was collapsing all around me, House of Usher style. It was also in that brain-fogged moment that I realized I have no training in how to respond in cases of earthquake/house collapses. Mostly I just screamed like a girl and rolled off the bed like a ninja, only to get my legged wrapped up in the duvet and flopped to the ground face first.
So anyways, heavy shower curtain means I keep it closed at all times now. And now I am constantly -- constantly -- convinced that someone is hiding behind the curtain. Too many horror movies combined with New Fear #2 (below) and the time that I was 11 and my cousin hid in the shower to scare me while I was brushing my teeth have trained me to be so paranoid that I can barely function in my bathroom until I have spent a couple of hair-raising moments darting over to the shower and peeking around it to verify that I am indeed alone so I can wash my hands free of fear.
New Fear #2 is way more insidious and way more crazy too: I constantly imagine that I'm being stalked. This one has been hanging around a lot, but is more prominent after the Signs watching. See, a few weeks back, I was cleaning up the kitchen super late (like around 11:00pm) and needed to take out the trash, for fear that the Black Plague that I just scrubbed away would take on sentience in the trash bag and kill me in my sleep. So I wandered down to the dumpster on the far side of the complex.
(To understand the next part, you have to have some idea of the layout of the complex. This particular side doesn't border on the street, instead we're up against a mini-forest; it's the treeline to the little creek that runs out from the park to the north. So the layout goes Street-> Buildings -> Dumpster -> Lawn -> Trees.)
I toss the trash into the dumpster and turn to head back to my building. Midway through the turn, I swear I see someone across the lawn standing along the treeline, staring at me. More precisely, it's a white guy in a really dark suit. He's standing in the shadows of the trees, and it's just for a second as I'm turning, but I can still make out enough to tell he looks bald and is most definitely looking in my direction. I freak the hell out (as one does) and start heading back to my apartment double-time. Only when I turn back after a couple of seconds, there's no one standing there. More importantly, the lightpost on the lawn is brightly illuminating the place where I supposedly saw this person - there's no way that it would have been dark enough to hide someone in the shadows.
I chalk it up to a completely overactive imagination (which I've got in spades - ask me about my law library sub-basement stories sometime), and head home, only mildly still freaking out.
Now, ever since then, I'm constantly expecting this guy to pop up somewhere. Whenever I go outside at night, I'm looking everywhere, all the time, alert like a cougar. I've seen nothing since then, but it doesn't mean I'm not going crazy.
-------------
So yeah, I'm crazy like whoa. It's not unexpected, but still, it's a little sad.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)